Protecting Our Children Online: What Can We Learn from the Instagram Lawsuit?


In today’s digital age, children navigate a complex online world. While social media platforms offer connection and entertainment, they can also pose significant risks.

The recent lawsuit against Instagram alleges that its practices harm children. This has sparked a crucial conversation: how can we ensure a safe online environment for our youth?

This article discusses the lessons learned from the lawsuit. We’ll explore its accusations, potential harm to children, and the critical steps needed to create a more responsible digital landscape.

The Allegations Against Instagram

The Instagram lawsuit, filed by dozens of US states, levies a series of grave accusations against Meta, its parent company. Central to the allegations is the claim that Meta deliberately misled the public. This is regarding the risks associated with social media usage, particularly concerning its impact on youth mental health.

According to BBC, the lawsuit contends that Meta engaged in deceptive conduct. It alleges that the company employed addictive features designed to “ensnare” users, all while concealing the substantial dangers inherent in its platforms.

Among the specific allegations are accusations of inadequate safeguards against cyberbullying and exploitation of children’s vulnerabilities for profit. Furthermore, Meta is accused of violating consumer protection laws by collecting data on children under the age of 13.

The lawsuit’s claims paint a disturbing picture of a social media giant prioritizing profits over the well-being of its users.

Potential Harms to Children

TorHoerman Law notes that children face a myriad of potential harms online, with social media platforms like Instagram being central to these risks. Mental health issues such as anxiety, depression, and body image concerns are prevalent among young users. These issues are exacerbated by unrealistic portrayals and harmful content on these platforms.

Ekō research from 2021 and 2023 underscores the severity of the problem. Findings reveal a troubling proliferation of problematic content targeting young users. The report provides concrete data on the alarming prevalence of harmful content on TikTok and Instagram.

The investigation uncovered over 33.26 million posts under hashtags associated with body image issues, mental health concerns, incel, and misogynistic content. Disturbingly, the volume of problematic content has increased significantly since previous research. Hashtags related to suicide, incel content, eating disorders, plastic surgery, and skin whitening exhibit substantial upticks.

Meanwhile, social media giants continue to profit from targeted advertising aimed at minors, raking in a staggering $11 billion in U.S. ad revenue. The contrast between the prevalence of harmful content on these platforms and the revenue generated from young users emphasizes the need for increased regulation. As children increasingly navigate the digital landscape, protecting their mental and emotional well-being must be a top priority.

Lessons Learned from the Lawsuit

The lawsuit against Instagram serves as a stark reminder of the urgent need for enhanced online child protection measures. One important takeaway from the legal battle is the urgent need for social media platforms to assume greater responsibility for moderating content. This includes ensuring user safety, especially for minors.

Platforms like Instagram must be held more accountable for implementing robust measures to safeguard young users from harmful content and predatory behavior.

Moreover, the lawsuit underscores the pressing need for greater transparency regarding how algorithms curate content and potentially target children. There is a growing call for social media companies to disclose their algorithms’ inner workings to ensure accountability and mitigate algorithmic bias.

In parallel, the role of parents in monitoring their children’s online activity emerges as a pivotal aspect of online child protection. While parental control tools have become increasingly available across various platforms, their adoption remains shockingly low.

According to The Washington Post, Meta’s internal research revealed that by 2022, fewer than 10 percent of teens on Instagram had enabled parental supervision. These findings underscore significant barriers for parents in utilizing these tools effectively. It suggests a critical need for better educational resources to empower parents and children with digital literacy skills and safe online behaviors.

By addressing these systemic weaknesses, the lessons learned from the lawsuit can pave the way for a more secure online environment for children.

Moving Forward: Solutions and Recommendations

The Instagram lawsuit serves as a wake-up call, urging us to create a safer online environment for children. Here’s a look at potential solutions:

  • Stronger platform regulations: Social media platforms need clearer guidelines for content moderation. Age-appropriate filters, stricter monitoring for cyberbullying and predator activity, and increased transparency in algorithmic curation are crucial. Holding platforms accountable for user safety, especially for minors, can create a more responsible online space.
  • Age verification with nuance:  While age verification tools can restrict access to inappropriate content, blanket restrictions might not be ideal.  Age-gating systems should be balanced with educational content verification that allows access to valuable resources while filtering out harmful material.
  • Investing in digital literacy: Education is key. Programs for both children and parents can foster responsible online behavior. Children can learn critical thinking skills to evaluate online content, identify red flags, and practice safe communication. Parents, equipped with these resources, can provide better guidance and supervision in the digital world.
  • Promoting quality over quantity: Encouraging healthier online habits goes beyond content moderation.  We need to shift the focus from excessive screen time and endless scrolling to prioritize quality interactions.  Promoting responsible online engagement helps children develop healthy digital habits that prioritize meaningful social interactions.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I keep my child safe on Instagram?

To ensure your child’s safety on Instagram, make sure their account is private. Access the profile page, go to Settings, select Privacy, and toggle on the Private Account option. This restricts viewing to approved followers only, enhancing control over who can see their posts and reducing exposure to potential risks.

Is Meta safe for kids?

The safety of children on Meta platforms like Facebook and Instagram depends on parental supervision and platform settings. While parental controls and privacy settings can enhance safety, it’s crucial to educate children about online risks. However, concerns persist regarding content moderation and algorithmic transparency, necessitating ongoing vigilance.

What are the risks of Instagram?

The risks of Instagram encompass various concerns. They include contact from strangers, exposure to inappropriate content, cyberbullying, and negative effects on mental and physical health. The direct messaging feature poses particularly significant risks, making supervision and precautionary measures essential.

In conclusion, the digital landscape offers endless possibilities for connection and exploration for children. However, the recent lawsuit against Instagram underscores the need for a more responsible online environment.

By learning from the case and implementing solutions, we can create a safer space for our youth. Let’s empower children with digital literacy skills, equip parents with the tools for responsible monitoring, and encourage platforms to prioritize user well-being.

Share this on


About the author

Related Articles

Scroll to Top